Up

Corruption in Wikileaks cables

(No, not the kind where money is involved. There certainly are such cables, but here we talk about damage to the text.)

Mainly two kinds of corruption occur: one that seems caused by bit noise: here and there a few bits are flipped, and one that seems caused by dropped bytes: once every line or so one symbol is dropped.

Corrupted bits

The cable 08BISHKEK1021 was given by Wikileaks in a rather corrupted version.

The Cable Headers files give two lines

2008-10-06T08:32:00Z,Embassy Bishkek,"PREL, PGGV, KPAK$ IC"
2008-10-06T08:32:00Z,Embassy Bishkek,"PREL, PGOV, KPAO, KG"
for cables 172634 and 172635, sent at the same time, where the former has some corrupted bits.

Wikileaks gives a cable they call 08SECTION01GF02BISHIEK21 since it is only the first half of a cable. But that cable is not 08BISHKEK21 but 08BISHKEK1021. Below the start as given, followed by an attempt to reconstruct the original. One sees that almost all errors are single bit errors, and that a 'Q' stands for an unknown corrupted sysmbol.

The start as given

2008-10-06
08BISHKEK1021

UNCLAS SECTION 01 GF 02 BISHIEK 00Q021 
 
SEFSITIVE 
SIPDIS 
 
DEPT BGR SCA+CEN AND SCA'PPD 
 
E.M. 12958: N'A 
TAGS: PREL PGGV KPAK IC
SUBJECT:  Libel S5iT3 Chill Fre% Sp%ech in KyR%yzStan 
 
BISHKEK 10061021  001.2 OF 002 
 
 
SEFSITIVE BUT UJCLASSIFIED.  NMT FGR IJTERFET DISTRIBUTIKF 
 
Q*  (SBU) SUMEARYQ A s5cce3sfU, libel suit b9 Pr%sidejT BakiyeV%s 
fephew agaibS4 t7k indepejdejt .ews0ap%rs has opened a veriT!bde 
f,kgd caTe T) addit)kfal cR)minal !jd aiV)l s5its agaibs4 
new3pap%rs.  T(e S5it3, W(ich can resulT in awa2ds ob oje millicn 
SomS (gV%r $28,Q00) in moR!l daeaces, ar% gften eboQch tk bafkrupQ a 
fewsp!peR gr fgr#e its cdoS5re.  END SUEMARI. 
 
Adibi ajd De FakT/ First in the Aro3shairs 
--%-----------------------------------%--- 
 
2.  (SBU) On JUne Q, in a libel s5it &ided bY Pr%sidejT Bakiyev%s 
fephew, Asylbek QaliyeV, the P%rvomaiSkY Raion Cour4 ru,ed acaijst 
)jdependenT neW3paperS "D% Fa#to" and "Alib)*"  The Court mrdered 
4he new3pap%rs tk 0ai QaliyeV kne million s/ms (cv%r $28,Q00) as 
"ckmPefs!tion for miral damage" f/r sucgest)jg 4haT Saliyev w!sQ 
ifvmlV%d ij a baT!l car craSh in M!rch 2005. 
 
Q.  (SBU) "De F!kt/" ness0ap%r#s ifitia, reacT)kf tk The akU2t 
ru,ifg sas to tr%at it as a jgke and S4aR4 a ccllecTikn from 
reader3, sayine, "We need gne milli/b sgeS in donatikns for the 
needY Pr%sidejT's family."  H/weV%r$ before it #cu,$ r!ise thE 
&undq$ )t aaain ran into 4rgU"de.  On JQje 10, "De Faktg" publiS(ed 
a qtatemejt by ZaiiRa Mildnzheva$ who identified heRself aS a Tah 
I.qpectiOn O&ficer ajd accUqed the Head of t(e K9rgyz T x I*sp%ctikb 
gf coRrup4ign.  Z!eira Mkddozheva was apparently an alias, and the 
author of the letter was never identified. 

Possible reading

2008-10-06
08BISHKEK1021

UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 02 BISHKEK 001021 
 
SENSITIVE 
SIPDIS 
 
DEPT FOR SCA/CEN AND SCA/PPD 
 
E.O. 12958: N/A 
TAGS: PREL PGOV KPAO KG
SUBJECT:  Libel Suits Chill Free Speech in Kyrgyzstan 
 
BISHKEK 00001021  001.2 OF 002 
 
 
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED.  NOT FOR INTERNET DISTRIBUTION 
 
1.  (SBU) SUMMARY: A successful libel suit by President Bakiyev's 
nephew against two independent newspapers has opened a veritable 
flood gate to additional criminal and civil suits against 
newspapers.  The suits, which can result in awards of one million 
soms (over $28,000) in moral damages, are often enough to bankrupt a 
newspaper or force its closure.  END SUMMARY. 
 
Alibi and De Fakto First in the Crosshairs 
------------------------------------------ 
 
2.  (SBU) On June 2, in a libel suit filed by President Bakiyev's 
nephew, Asylbek Saliyev, the Pervomaisky Rayon Court ruled against 
independent newspapers "De Facto" and "Alibi."  The Court ordered 
the newspapers to pay Saliyev one million soms (over $28,000) as 
"compensation for moral damage" for suggesting that Saliyev was 
involved in a fatal car crash in March 2007. 
 
3.  (SBU) "De Fakto" newspaper's initial reaction to the court 
ruling was to treat it as a joke and start a collection from 
readers, saying, "We need one million soms in donations for the 
needy President's family."  However, before it could raise the 
funds, it again ran into trouble.  On June 14, "De Fakto" published 
a statement by Zamira Moldozheva, who identified herself as a Tax 
Inspection Officer and accused the Head of the Kyrgyz Tax Inspection 
of corruption.  Zamira Moldozheva was apparently an alias, and the 
author of the letter was never identified. 
There is more in this cable, but the rest does not have bit corruption. Statistics over this part, ignoring source byte 'Q': 1442 bytes correct, 267 bytes with single-bit error, 17 bytes with double-bit error, 1 byte with triple-bit error. Some bits are more vulnerable than others: among the single-bit errors 2, 16, 49, 47, 3, 57, 93 are in bit 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, respectively. There is no obvious pattern in the errors.

(I improved the reading of 7 bytes, but have not updated the statistics.)

Somewhat similarly, in 08ATHENS1350:

He hopes 
his efforts will lead to increased coordination, hopefully 
improving the West's negotiating position i& &54QQ% !$)%!4%QQ 
change negotiations.  S)Q$!!!))1 34Q$Q1%$ Q(% )%portance of 
the ECCC T) hiS %"baRQQ Ta !)iRdinate a broad range of 
$!#"QQ)#!!Q$%!Q!)!Q )Qques with other ministries$ "!QQ"! )"QQ 
QQQQ)!QQ!r that he was upbeat on ()1 I@R ! "#2QQQ Group" he 
(!Q ""%!Q$$ 5"$$Q the aegis of his interagency IPR Committee. 
Also 08ATHENS1427 has a fragment with a burst of bit noise.

Lost bytes

An entirely different phenomenon is seen in cables like 06BEIRUT3128 or 07THEHAGUE1295. In the 06BEIRUT3128 (as given by Aftenposten) Sections 4 and 5 read
4. (S)
Pedersen was at a loss to explain why Kofi Annan would come up
with an idea that "is_so wrong." The end result, Pedersen said,
will be that the UN loses its political expertise on Lebanon, as
Terje Roed-Larsen will join Pedersen in_leaving. Pedersen
expressed consternation that Annan would take what Pedersen saw
as a radical and misguided step, and one that will cause
upheaval_in the UN's ability to deal with Lebanon issues, in his
last months in office. He expressed hope that the USG would
join France in trying to dissuade Annan of formally appointing
Fischer. Perhaps,_Pedersen said, the USG can quietly whisper to
Fischer himself why it would be better for him not to accept.

5. (S)
Comment: Pedersen -- like Larsen -- has self-interest in seeing
that Fischer's appointment does not happen. While Pedersen has
years of experience dealing with Terje Roed-Larsen and can
adjust his own work to Larsen's UNSCR 159 role, Fischer would
probably see himself as more of a traditional supervisor to
Geir's office (whch for all practical purposes is currently
independent). But we agree with Pedersen's analysis that the
Lebanese will not view Fischer as a credible, neutral envoy. In
the context of what else Germany is doing these days in
Lebanon, he will be seen as part of a German plan to "protect
Israel" at the expense of Lebanon's sovereignty. It is amusing
to speculate whether Larsen or Fischer would be viewed with
greater alarm by Hizballah. End_comment.
(where missing symbols are given in red, and _ denotes a missing space). We see that roughly one out of every 48 bytes is missing.

In 09CAIRO353, Section 5:

want the U.S. now to commit to raising ESF (or some other
compensatory arrangement such as debt relief) to a level that
demonstrates U.S. respect for the relationship. We understand
that the GOE has been discussing the matter internally and
would be prepared to accede to the FY2009 levels if the U.S.
will commit to a review of the program with everything on the
table: future funding levels, possible endowment_arrangements,
and democracy and governance programming. There are strong
Egyptian expectations that the ESF level should be increased.

Or again in 07THEHAGUE1295, Section 15:

15. (C) Kleiweg noted that the Dutch have yet to formally
solicit contributions from other NATO Allies to any Dutch
extension in Uruzgan. He said the GONL first will identify
options and possible tasks that could be filled by others
prior to approaching Allies. Kleiweg acknowledged that the
Dutch are ""picky"" when_it comes to the question of which
Allies to approach -- any potential partner has to ""speak the
same language"" and possess a ""similar outlook"" when it comes
to reconstruction efforts. He also noted_a certain
reluctance on the part of the Dutch military to incorporate
elements from yet another military -- but such hesitancy will
need to be overcome should the review determine the best
chance of an extension involves teaming with another Ally.
with a similar effect.

Funny: a NRC journalist read this cable and concluded that ambassador Arnall was a bit drunk while typing this. (So many typos in a few sentences...)

Af en toe lijkt het alsof de auteur pas na de borrel aan zijn verslag is begonnen.
Leonie van Nierop, NRC 2011-01-18, p.2

Header corruption

The two cables 09CONAKRY766 and 09BRUSSELS196 have very similar header corruption. The former also has trailing garbage, The strings Normal, Default Paragraph Font, Table Normal, No Spacing might be from a Word document. The cables 06TRIPOLI358, 06TRIPOLI561, 07TRIPOLI169, 07TRIPOLI426, 07TRIPOLI487, 07TRIPOLI834 have a binary header containing strings like __nameid_version1.0, __properties_version1.0, __substg1.0.

Letter Q

Not a corruption but a convention is to indicate a duplicated line with an initial 'Q'. E.g.,
the latest. Drawing on Shell's experience, he described
Qthe latest. Drawing on Shell's experience, he described

Since these texts are often reformatted, this duplication indicator is also found at other line positions. E.g.,

Secretary Locke did not happen. Her Ministry of Economic
Affairs (MEA) spans energy, commerce, and trade. Qof Economic
Affairs (MEA) spans energy, commerce, and trade. In the past