Comparison of two versions of 10ASTANA72.html. Source for the first: Wikileaks torrents up to cablegate-201101081029.7z. Source for the second: Wikileaks nontorrent releases as mirrorred by privet on 201101130839, by aeb e.g. on 201101131330 and 201101171315.

The first is redacted, with deletions indicated by xxxxx. The second has fragments of text, here shown in red replacing the xxxxx.

See also Israel Shamir's note Redacting Corruption.

VZCZCXRO6688
PP RUEHBI RUEHCI RUEHDBU RUEHFL RUEHKW RUEHLA RUEHLH RUEHNEH
RUEHNP
RUEHPW RUEHROV RUEHSL
DE RUEHTA #0072/01 0250814
ZNY SSSSS ZZH
P 250814Z JAN 10
FM AMEMBASSY ASTANA
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 7265
INFO RUCNCLS/ALL SOUTH AND CENTRAL ASIA COLLECTIVE PRIORITY
RUCNCIS/CIS COLLECTIVE PRIORITY 2396
RUEHZL/EUROPEAN POLITICAL COLLECTIVE PRIORITY
RUEHBJ/AMEMBASSY BEIJING PRIORITY 1758
RUEHUL/AMEMBASSY SEOUL PRIORITY 1374
RUEHKO/AMEMBASSY TOKYO PRIORITY 2464
RUEAWJA/DEPT OF JUSTICE WASHDC PRIORITY
RHMFISS/CDR USCENTCOM MACDILL AFB FL PRIORITY
RUEAIIA/CIA WASHDC PRIORITY
RUCPDOC/DEPT OF COMMERCE WASHINGTON DC PRIORITY
RHMFISS/DEPT OF ENERGY WASHINGTON DC PRIORITY
RHEFAAA/DIA WASHDC PRIORITY
RUEKJCS/JOINT STAFF WASHDC PRIORITY
RHEHNSC/NSC WASHDC PRIORITY 1954
RUEKJCS/SECDEF WASHDC PRIORITY 1804
RUEHNO/USMISSION USNATO PRIORITY 2973
RUCNDT/USMISSION USUN NEW YORK PRIORITY 2683
Monday, 25 January 2010, 08:14
S E C R E T SECTION 01 OF 03 ASTANA 000072
SIPDIS
STATE FOR SCA/CEN, EEB
EO 12958 DECL: 01/25/2030
TAGS PGOV, PINR, EPET, EINV, KCOR, RS, CH, KZ
SUBJECT: KAZAKHSTAN: MONEY AND POWER
REF: ASTANA 0061
Classified By: Ambassador Richard E. Hoagland: 1.4 (b), (d)

¶1. (S) SUMMARY: During a private dinner, KazMunaiGaz First
Vice President Maksat Idenov named, in his view, the four
most powerful gate-keepers around President Nursultan
Nazarbayev: Chief of Administration and General Services of
the President's Office Sarybai Kalmurzayev, the President's
Chief of Staff Aslan Musin, State Secretary-Foreign Minister
Kanat Saudabayev, and the tandem of Prime Minister Karim
Masimov and Nazarbayev's billionaire son-in-law Timur
Kulibayev. According to Idenov, in Kazakhstan, market economy
means capitalism, which means big money, which means
large bribes for the best connected. The following details
are a single snapshot of one version of current reality. The
significant point is that Nazarbayev is standing with Idenov,
not Kulibayev, to maintain international standards to develop
the massive Kashagan and Karachaganak hydrocarbon projects.
END SUMMARY.

¶2. (S) On January 21, KazMunaiGaz First Vice President
Maksat Idenov and the Ambassador had a one-on-one dinner in a
nearly empty restaurant (times are still hard!) at the
Radisson hotel in Astana. When the Ambassador arrived, Idenov
was barking into his cell phone, "Mark, Mark, stop the
excuses! Mark, listen to me! Mark, shut up right now and do
as I say! Bring the letter to my office at 10:00 pm, and we
will go together to take it to (Minister of Energy and
Mineral Resources, MEMR) Mynbayev at his house." On ending
the call, Idenov explained he was talking to British Gas (BG)
Country Director for Kazakhstan Mark Rawlings who had missed
the deadline to deliver a letter about arbitration on the
Karachaganak super-giant oil-field project (reftel). Still
clearly steamed, Idenov alleged, "He's still playing games
with Mercator's James Giffin," the notorious AmCit fixer
indicted for large-scale bribery on oil deals in the 1990s,
whose case drags on in the Southern District Court of New
York. "I tell him, ‘Mark, stop being an idiot! Stop
tempting fate! Stop communicating with an indicted
criminal!'" Idenov asked, "Do you know how much he
(Rawlings) makes? $72,000 a month! A month!! Plus benefits!
Plus bonuses! Lives in Switzerland but supposedly works in
London. Comes here once a month to check in. Nice life, huh?"

¶3. (S) Idenov calmed down and said, "Let's look at the
menus." Then he immediately started typing on his PDA and
turned the screen toward the Ambassador, saying, "Let's look
at the ‘four courses.'" On the screen were four names:
Kalmurzayev, Musin, Saudabayev, and Masimov-Kulibayev."
Idenov said, "The Big Four around Number One." (NOTE: Sarybai
Kalmurzayev, currently the head of Administration and General
Services in the Presidential Administration, was, among other
jobs, a former head of the Financial Police and, before that,
in the 1990s, in charge of privatization. Aslan Musin is the
current Chief of Staff for Nazarbayev. Kanat Saudabayev, a
personal friend of Nazarbayev for nearly 40 years, is
Minister of State and Foreign Minister. Karim Masimov is
Prime Minister, and Timur Kulibayev is currently the favored
presidential son-in-law, on the Forbes 500 list of
billionaires (as is his wife separately), and the ultimate
controller of 90% of the economy of Kazakhstan. END NOTE.) In
response to a question, Idenov said that Masimov has a degree
of freedom, but never acts without permission from "the
hyphen" (Kulibayev). Then Idenov stood up abruptly and
carried his PDA to a ledge about 20 feet from the table and
asked the Ambassador to turn off his cell phone.

¶4. (S) Idenov said he wanted to explain why he has been
less visible for at least the last half year. Starting last
spring, all the "Big Four" (on the menu) began blocking him
from seeing President Nazarbayev. In October, KMG President

ASTANA 00000072 002 OF 003

Kairgeldy Kabyldin told Idenov, "Kulibayev doesn't want to
work with you any more." Idenov said he replied, "Fine,"
immediately returned to his office, wrote his letter of
resignation, and packed up his personal files and photos of
his family." He said Mynbayev immediately called and asked,
"My dear friend, what are you doing?!" Idenov said he was fed
up and was going to the Middle East to work -- "I want out of
here!" PM Masimov called and said, "Nazarbayev wants to know
how you're doing. He'd really like to see you when you have
time." Idenov, who said he'd been trying to see the President
for months but had been blocked by the "Big Four," went to
see the President and told him, "Kabyldin says Kulibayev
doesn't want to work with me any more." Idenov said the
President told him to calm down: "It's probably just evil
gossip. I'll have Karim (Masimov) talk to Timur (Kulibayev).
Then Idenov went to Masimov and told him, "OK, I'll stay, but
how do I deal with this?" Masimov said he'd talk to both
Kabyldin and Kulibayev.

¶5. (S) Soon, intermediaries arranged an Idenov-Kulibayev
meeting. Idenov said they both pretended to ignore the core
problem -- Kulibayev's, he alleged, avarice for large bribes.
Idenov averred he told Kulibayev, "Please watch your image
and reputation. You have a real opportunity to improve your
own image and the image of the nation." Idenov said Kulibayev
was "like a Buddha with a Paris manicure," and both
understood life would continue. Idenov said he believes he
has, so far, the president's protection. "But the games
continue," he said. Idenov alleged that both both BG and Italy's
ENI are corrupt -- and Kulibayev is salivating to profit from
them -- but, so far, Idenov stands in the way. "So long as
Nazarbayev says he wants Kashagan and Karachaganak developed
according to international standards, that's what I'll do."

¶6. (SBU) (NOTE: Fugitive former CEO of BTA bank, Mukhtar
Ablyazov, accused of embezzling over $1 billion, recently
leaked "documentary evidence" to the international media that
China's state companies have bribed Kulibayev over $100
million in recent months for oil deals. END NOTE.)

¶7. (S) The Ambassador asked if the corruption and
infighting are worse now than before. Idenov paused, thought,
and then replied, "No, not really. It's business as usual."
Idenov brushed off a question if the current maneuverings are
part of a succession struggle. "Of course not. It's too early
for that. As it's always been, it's about big money.
Capitalism -- you call it market economy -- means huge money.
Listen, almost everyone at the top is confused. They're
confused by their Soviet mentality. They're confused by the
corrupt excesses of capitalism. ‘If Goldman Sachs
executives can make $50 million a year and then run America's
economy in Washington, what's so different about what we do?'
they ask."

OTHER TIDBITS

¶8. (S) MODEST WEALTH. Idenov alleged that MEMR's Mynbayev
is among the richest in Kazakhstan but "flies under the
radar" because he is a relatively modest and very
hard-working technocrat. His great wealth derives, in part,
from his former ownership of KazKommerzBank -- "But he never
flaunts it."

¶9. (S) VULTURES. Idenov alleged that GazProm and China
National Petroleum Company "continue to circle like
vultures," hoping that the Kashagan and Karachaganak
consortia will implode, and then they can pick up the pieces.
"Won't happen on my watch!" Idenov vowed.

¶10. (C) HOW TO ORDER LAMB. Idenov insisted the Ambassador
order a bottle of wine for their dinner but then never
touched his first glass. Instead, he gulped three cans of
Coca-Cola while inhaling his food. When both he and the
Ambassador ordered lamb chops, Idenov advised, "Well done,

ASTANA 00000072 003 OF 003

never rare -- this is Astana, not London!"

¶11. (S) COMMENT: Idenov is effusive, even theatrical, by
nature. When he trusts, he spills his heart. Of course,
there's no doubt he also spins his own narrative, as we all
do. And so, this dinner is simply a snapshot -- but, we would
judge, a relatively accurate glimpse of one version of
current reality. The significant point is that Nazarbayev is
standing with Idenov, not Kulibayev, to maintain
international standards to develop the massive Kashagan and
Karachaganak hydrocarbon projects. END COMMENT.

HOAGLAND