S E C R E T SECTION 01 OF 04 ALGIERS 000039
SIPDIS
NOFORN
EO 12958 DECL: 01/11/2020
TAGS PREL, PTER, PGOV, PINR, MOPS, AG, US
SUBJECT: ALGERIAN FM: TSA LISTING “INTOLERABLE,
INAPPROPRIATE, INOPPORTUNE”
REF: A. ALGIERS 20 (NOTAL) B. STATE 001187
ALGIERS 00000039 001.2 OF 004
Classified By: Ambassador David D Pearce; reasons 1.4 (b) and (d).
Summary
-------
¶1. (S/NF) Foreign Minister Mourad Medelci January 11 summoned
the Ambassador and forcefully objected to Algeria’s placement
on the TSA enhanced screening list. He termed the decision
intolerable, inappropriate, and inopportune. It reflected
neither the reality of Algeria’s security situation, its
counterterrorism efforts nor our close bilateral cooperation.
Further, the U.S. had not communicated the TSA decision to
Algeria prior to releasing it to the press, which was how the
GOA had learned of the measure. The GOA now had to contend
with not only the collective humiliation felt by domestic
opinion but also incomplete and inaccurate information
regarding Algeria’s CT efforts circulating in the
international press as a result of the story. Medelci
reinforced the earlier MFA demarche (ref A) formally
requesting removal from the list and a high-level U.S.
statement to help correct the record regarding Algerian
cooperation on counterterrorism. He pointedly asked the
Ambassador to communicate this message to the Secretary and
said the GOA would be monitoring the U.S. reaction closely.
End Summary.
TSA Decision Ignores Reality of CT Cooperation
--------------------------------------------- -
¶2. (S/NF) Algerian Minister of Foreign Affairs Mourad Medelci
summoned the Ambassador to the MFA January 11 to underscore
Algeria’s dissatisfaction with its placement on TSA’s enhanced
screening list. Medelci began by noting he had had a
productive visit to Washington in early December. He had been
favorably impressed with both the quality and level of his
meetings and had appreciated their focus on bilateral security
and counterterrorism cooperation. The visit had underscored
the strategic importance of our countries’ counterterrorism
partnership on this sensitive issue. “We are confident in the
direction this cooperation is leading,” he remarked. “After my
visit, I was eager to report my discussions in Washington to
President Bouteflika, meetings which demonstrated that our
relations have reached a new level.”
¶3. (S/NF) The discussions in Washington, he asserted,
reflected the reality of the relationship. Algeria’s own
struggle against terrorism and its contribution to defeat
terrorists were well understood. It remained determined to
continue that cooperation and reinforce the relationship with
the U.S. “We are aware of the risks this threat poses. We must
remain vigilant and preserve the progress that has been made,”
Medelci said. The progress that both sides have made on the
ground underscores the confidence and openness of the
strategic partnership.
¶4. (S/NF) Therefore, the minister said, the GOA had been
extremely disappointed with Algeria’s inclusion in the TSA
list, as well as the press coverage the decision had
generated. The decision was intolerable, inappropriate, and
inopportune. It was a contradiction not only to Algeria’s
ALGIERS 00000039 002.2 OF 004
own progress on security and efforts to fight terrorism, but
also to our countries’ counterterrorism cooperation. No
attacks against the U.S. had been “signed” by an Algerian.
Algeria had made major progress in recent years on its
internal security. The domestic security environment had been
stabilized, airports were secure, and Algeria was now an
international partner in the fight against terrorism. TSA’s
announcement had made no mention of any of this.
Measures Viewed as Discriminatory
---------------------------------
¶5. (S/NF) This was not just a matter of Algeria’s inclusion
on the list, Medelci said. The GOA protested the
discriminatory nature of the whole list. Thirteen of the 14
countries listed were Muslim. This sent a message that was
inconsistent with President Obama’s Cairo speech, and the
administration’s stated policy of outreach to Muslim
communities. The decision will likely give further impetus to
those who already question the sincerity of the
administration’s approach.
¶6. (S/NF) The GOA was also disappointed, Medelci continued,
that the decision had not been communicated prior to its
release and that the Algerian leadership had to learn of it
via the media. The minister said the GOA had initially
refrained from making a public statement out of concern for
U.S. relations, but now, due to the extensive press play and
sense of collective humiliation among the public, it felt it
needed to respond.
U.S. Focus on Air Travel Safety
-------------------------------
¶7. (S/NF) The Ambassador said the intention behind the TSA
measures was not to harm or discriminate against any group or
country, least of all our friends and partners. The intention
was to make air travel as safe as possible for all. The
problem was that, on Christmas day, a terrorist had gotten
through the system. President Obama had reacted immediately,
ordering reviews of both our watch list system and our air
passenger screening measures. He had also made clear that our
approach would not be static but would evolve as our
evaluation of the risk evolved. Algeria’s concerns would be
reported in full; Washington had already heard the message
from Ambassador Baali. The Ambassador added that the U.S.
understood well Algeria’s difficult history with terrorism and
appreciated its leadership in the international fight against
extremist violence. The U.S. wanted to continue, and build on,
our very important counterterrorism cooperation as well as our
new partnerships in other areas, including military relations,
law enforcement, and economic and trade cooperation.
Going Forward
-------------
¶8. (S/NF) Medelci said the GOA shared the desire to continue
building our bilateral relationship. He reconfirmed GOA
approval for a recent U.S. request to allow overflights of
EP-3E surveillance aircraft. He also welcomed the visit of
U.S. Attorney General Holder to conclude work on a mutual
legal assistance treaty. The minister underscored as well the
GOA’s readiness to assist with the upcoming Department of
ALGIERS 00000039 003.2 OF 004
Commerce trade mission to Algeria in February and offered to
meet with the head of the U.S. delegation, schedule
permitting. At the same time, he asked that the Ambassador
convey his message on Algeria’s concerns about the TSA
measures to Secretary Clinton. The GOA shared the U.S. desire
to continue building the bilateral relationship. But it would
also be watching closely to see how the U.S. responds to its
stated concerns and looking forward to an “equitable
solution”.
GOA Statement
-------------
¶10. (U) Below is Embassy’s informal translation of the
statement issued January 11 by the Algerian MFA:
The Minister of Foreign Affairs, Mourad Medelci, summoned
Monday the Ambassador of the United States of America in
Algiers to express the Algerian government’s strong protest
over the decision taken by U.S. authorities to include
Algerian nationals on a list of countries whose nationals are
subjected to specific control measures when arriving and
departing U.S. airports:
“In the wake of the decision taken by the U.S. authorities to
include Algerian nationals on a list of countries whose
nationals will be subjected to specific control measures when
arriving and departing U.S. airports, Foreign Affairs Minister
Mourad Medelci summoned the Ambassador of the United States of
America in Algiers to express the Algerian government’s strong
protests over the unfortunate, unjustified, and discriminatory
measure.
“This comes after several previous efforts that were deployed,
once the TSA measures were known, by the central government
and by our Ambassador in Washington with the relevant U.S.
authorities.”
END INFORMAL TRANSLATION OF GOA STATEMENT.
COMMENT
-------
¶11. (S/NF) The past year has seen developments in important
new areas of government-to-government cooperation. These
include:
-- Approval for visits by senior Department of Defense
visitors, including Deputy Assistant Secretary Huddleston and
the first by AFRICOM Commander General Ward. These have
significantly improved the substance of our mil-mil
engagement.
-- Prompt agreement to allow U.S. military overflights for
surveillance aircraft against AQIM targets in the Sahel.
-- Repatriation of eight Algerian Guantanamo detainees since
2008 and agreement to cooperate on the return of the remaining
Algerian detainees.
-- Bilateral cooperation on judicial matters; a mutual legal
assistance treaty and a customs agreement are both ready for
signature.
ALGIERS 00000039 004.2 OF 004
-- Cooperation with our new legatt office, including on a
cybercrime investigation that will protect American citizens
from hackers and identity thieves.
-- Improved police contacts and access for RSO, which plans to
launch an anti-terrorism assistance program this year.
¶12. (S/NF) On the commercial side, the U.S. exported about
USD 400 million in oil field equipment and services to Algeria
in 2008 and imported USD 19 billion worth of Algerian oil and
natural gas. And our commercial interests are rapidly
expanding beyond the hydrocarbons sector. Algeria signed two
contracts, totaling USD 847 million, in December 2009, to
purchase 11 Boeing aircraft. These were presidential
decisions, made in the face of heavy French pressure for
Airbus. A U.S. firm, Solar Turbines, concluded a USD
320-million contract in October 2009 with Algeria’s state
electricity company to supply gas-fired turbines. U.S.
companies are also competing for politically sensitive
security contracts. Cogent, a U.S. biometrics company, is
close to signing a USD 45-million deal to supply the Ministry
of Interior with an automated fingerprint identification
system but faces heavy competition from France. Harris Radio
is bidding on a contract with a potential value of USD 500
million to manufacture and supply radios for Algeria’s defense
ministry and signals corps. The Harris and Cogent contracts
have significant implications for U.S. commercial and security
interests.
¶13. (S/NF) It is noteworthy that Medelci began and ended this
conversation by stressing the importance the Algerian
leadership attaches to continuing bilateral cooperation,
especially on counterterrorism. But in-between, however, he
delivered an unmistakable message that the GOA feels the TSA
moves are inconsistent with that relationship and that they
will be watching closely to see how we respond to this
demarche. Over the past year, we have had a green light to
develop important new ties across the board, from military to
law enforcement. That light has now turned yellow.
PEARCE